SHUTTLE/Times & News readers are divided on whether the 24 hour licensing laws have been a success.

So far 54.2 per cent think the laws have failed while 45.8 per cent think they have been a success.

This week's review of the laws claimed crime and alcohol consumption was down overall but some areas had seen a rise in disorder and drink-related violence in the early hours.

Do you think the laws have been a success? Vote now.